Skip to main content
blog | What is a Closed-Loop System? |
2 minute read

When learning about servo motors and servo systems, you’re likely to encounter the phrase “closed-loop system.” If you’ve ever wondered what that means and how it works, you’ve come to the right place. Let’s step through some of the most common questions.

What is a closed loop? Aren’t loops always closed?

When you visualize some familiar loops we see around us—roller coasters, racetracks, key rings—they all share a basic characteristic: The end meets back up with the beginning. The same concept can apply to servo loops. The control system issues a command to the drive; the drive sends power to the motor; and the motor’s response—speed and position—are communicated back to the control system, closing the loop. The goal is for the feedback to match the command.

But what, technically speaking, closes a servo motor loop? 

The one-word answer engineers often give is “feedback,” but this is only partially true. Closed-loop systems do rely on devices that provide torque, speed and position feedback, but the loop is only closed after the control does something with the feedback data.

For example, the drive control issues a command, or rather a target, telling the drive to move the motor at 1,500 rpm. The drive energizes the motor, and the motor responds. But if the feedback device communicates to the control that the motor is only moving at 500 rpm, the drive control registers an error. Here lies the heart of the servo system. Recognizing that 500 rpm is not correct, the drive control makes a new calculation for what it would take to get the motor to spin 1,500 rpm and adjusts the current accordingly.

So, what’s happening inside the drive to close the feedback control loop?

The loop is closed as feedback data enters a summing junction in the control system that calculates an error—the difference between the target and the actual—and the drive control issues a new command to compensate. All of this can happen very quickly, hundreds of times faster than the blink of an eye, and the process repeats continuously.

But what if I want to regulate something else, like torque or position versus velocity control?

For a servo system there are multiple loops. The primary loop is the current loop. Current translates to torque at the motor. The current loop in the drive receives a command, then sends current to the motor. The sensing device inside the drive measures the current and sends the value back into the summing junction. If an error exists, the drive adjusts to correct the current. But what if the target current is not correct to achieve the target velocity and/or position? This is why there are additional loops.

The second loop is the velocity loop. The feedback for this loop is typically attached to the motor or the object in motion. The feedback is sent back to the drive control. The difference here is that if a velocity error exists, the control issues a new current command into the primary current loop. In other words, the velocity loop feeds its error into the current loop. As the current changes, velocity changes, and both loops review the feedback data for errors.

The third loop is the position loop. As you can imagine, the process is the same. Target position compared to actual position results in a position error that gets sent to the velocity loop as a new command. The velocity loop works as described above to provide a target current. The three loops work simultaneously to achieve the target position. 

Servo Motor Diagram 

To summarize, in order to regulate position, velocity, torque or another system parameter like pressure or tension, there must be associated feedback into one of the control loops so that the loop can be closed.

If we call this a closed-loop system, can there be an open-loop system?

Although it’s common to see the term open-loop, this could be considered a misnomer since it really means “no loop.” The reality is the loop doesn’t exist until we close it with feedback.

In an open-loop system you have an expectation of the outcome, but since you are not measuring it you really don’t know what is happening at the load. You could take an inherently open-loop system, like a stepper system, and add a feedback device for position or velocity. Essentially, you’re recognizing that potential loops exist, and you’re closing them. This does happen, and it’s why you’ll see feedback devices for steppers—usually with the phrase “servo-like” somewhere in the product description.

But then the question becomes, if you’re taking a stepper motor and closing one or more loops:

At what point should you just go with a servo system?

Good question. That’s when you should consider contacting a motion expert to discuss your specific application needs.

Consult an Expert

AKMA Servo Motors

The lightweight AKMA servo motor is designed for harsh environments like food and beverage processing, and delivers performance and reliability.
Learn More

AKD Servo Drive

AKD® Series is a proven perfomer, supporting the largest customer installed base, and offers:

  • Industry leading motion control loops
  • Extensive motor feedback and drive fieldbus support including EtherCAT, EtherNet/IP, Profinet RT, etc.
  • Plug-and-play with Kollmorgen motors
  • WorkBench GUI, acclaimed for customer experience and usability
Learn More

Engineer the Exceptional

Learn how to engineer exceptional machines, robots and vehicles with the highest-performing, most reliable motors, drives, automation solutions and more.

Learn More

Related Resources

Adjusting Standard Motion Profiles to Optimize Operating Speed and Time >

Adjusting Standard Motion Profiles to Optimize Operating Speed and Time: Learn more about simple profile adjustments that can preserve motion, move time and provide memorable profiles.​​​​

Accelerating the Development of Next-Generation Prostheses and Exoskeletons >

Learn how Kollmorgen servo technology is helping OEMs accelerate the design of next-generation prostheses and exoskeletons.

Kollmorgen and Stereotaxis Advance the Precision and Safety of Surgical Robots >

Kollmorgen’s advanced motion products and expertise are helping save and improve lives. Learn how the new Genesis surgical robot incorporates torque-dense AKM servo motors with specialized, integrated encoders to revolutionize cardiac ablation…
Direct Drive Technology Increases the Speed and Quality of Electric Vehicle Lithium-Ion Battery Production

Direct Drive Technology Increases the Speed and Quality of Electric Vehicle Lithium-Ion Battery Production  >

One important stage in manufacturing lithium-ion batteries for electric vehicles is seal-welding the positive-terminal top cap to the battery shell. Laser welding is the ideal technology for this purpose, but it requires precise motion, speed and…
Ground satellite 

AKD2G 24A Data Sheet >

Kollmorgen’s new AKD2G 24A servo drive delivers 3x the continuous current capacity and offers a rich feature set for simple integration in complex applications. 
Kollmorgen Express Delivery significantly shortens lead times for the company’s most popular motion products

Kollmorgen Express Delivery significantly shortens lead times for the company’s most popular motion products >

Motion leader Kollmorgen announces a new classification for select products that can be delivered within an accelerated timeframe.

From the Factory to the Farm: Unleashing the Power of Kollmorgen's Servo Motor Technology >

As smart automation increases farm productivity, there is a need for powerful, precise motors that can handle a wide range of heavy-duty tasks, day in and day out. But even the most advanced technology doesn’t change the basic nature of farming.
Surgical robotic arms in operating room.

Advanced Surgical Robots: Designing Compact, Powerful Motion for the Next Generation >

Learn the key criteria for designing axially compact arm joints that minimize space, maximize torque, and deliver precision performance in surgical robots.
Kollmorgen’s low-temperature servo technology simplifies cleaning of solar energy heliostats

Kollmorgen’s low-temperature servo technology simplifies cleaning of solar energy heliostats >

The development of photovoltaic and thermal solar energy—along with China’s rapidly growing capacity to manufacture them—has opened many new opportunities for sustainable energy production in international markets. At the same time, the demand for…