Skip to main content
blog | The Big Debate – Stepper vs Servo |
2 minute read

What is the best motor technology to use in a motion control application? There are numerous technologies to create motion, from hydraulic to pneumatic or electromechanical. In the world of precision motion control, many machine designers face a choice between step motor or servo motor technologies to solve their performance requirements. Both stepper motors and servo motors have a place in the motion control world but understanding when to use each has created a big debate.

Let’s check in on the ongoing debate of stepper vs servo…

Engineer A: “I like using stepper motors. They are simple to use, easy to set up and are reliable. I don’t need a lot of fancy control schemes to get my system from point A to point B.”

Engineer B: “I prefer a servo motor. The ability to cover a wide speed and torque range suits my multi-axis machine design perfectly.”

The engineers in this debate come from two different industries and have vastly different mechanical systems. Engineer A likes the simplicity of the stepper motor – from its set up and operation to how easy it is to get up and running. Based on the comment about point-to-point positioning, Engineer A has likely chosen the best solution for their particular machine. Stepper motors are a solid choice for simple point to point applications where load disturbances are minimal. Engineer B prefers the broad capabilities of servo motors, which makes sense in applications that require precise control and have multiple axes of coordinated motion. The high bandwidth and precision control of closed loop servo motors makes tight coordinated motion possible for multi-axis machinery.

Engineer B: “I had a bad experience with stepper motors when we attempted to use them on an axis with varying load disturbances.”

Engineer A: “I tried using a servo, but when it reached position it moved back and forth slightly as it came to a stop, which caused issues in the product finish.”

When Engineer B used a stepper motor on an axis that had some unpredictable load disturbances, some of these variations caused the motor to lose count, which eventually caused position errors. While this issue can be corrected by adding feedback to the stepper motor, it highlights one application where the open loop stepper may not be the best choice. In Engineer A’s case, an improperly tuned servo motor may “hunt” for position. Move and settle times can vary from application to application depending on motor sizing, inertia mismatch, and servo loop tuning. In the case of a simple point to point move with minimal load disturbances, a stepper motor is likely a better choice to stop at the designated point and hold position without hunting.

For Engineer A, the simple point to point positioning was best served using a stepper motor, while for Engineer B, the multi-axis coordination was better accommodated with servo motors. This “debate” explores only a few attributes that can influence the choice of servo vs stepper. To help determine which motor technology best fits each situation, Kollmorgen reviews numerous application attributes in the white paper “Stepper Motor vs Servo Motor – Which Should it Be?”

Consult an Expert

AKMA Servo Motors

The lightweight AKMA servo motor is designed for harsh environments like food and beverage processing, and delivers performance and reliability.
Learn More

Engineer the Exceptional

Learn how to engineer exceptional machines, robots and vehicles with the highest-performing, most reliable motors, drives, automation solutions and more.

Learn More

Related Resources

Accelerating the Development of Next-Generation Prostheses and Exoskeletons >

Learn how Kollmorgen servo technology is helping OEMs accelerate the design of next-generation prostheses and exoskeletons.

From the Factory to the Farm: Unleashing the Power of Kollmorgen's Servo Motor Technology >

As smart automation increases farm productivity, there is a need for powerful, precise motors that can handle a wide range of heavy-duty tasks, day in and day out. But even the most advanced technology doesn’t change the basic nature of farming.

Stop, hold and go safely: Motion tuning for vertical loads >

When designing motion for applications such as vertical gantries and hoists, you need to take special care to ensure operator safety and operational efficiency. Let’s discuss best practices for meeting the particular challenges involved.

What are the Five Major Components of a Brushless Servo Motor >

Servo motors are used in numerous markets to power machines, instruments, robots, and other factory automation applications. This blog addresses five major elements of a conventional brushless DC servo motor: the rotor, stator, bearings, feedback and…
What is a closed-loop system?

What is a Closed-Loop System? >

When learning about servo motors and servo systems, you’re likely to encounter the phrase “closed-loop system.” If you’ve ever wondered what that means and how it works, you’ve come to the right place. Let’s step through some of the most common…

Get Exact Positioning Without the Complexity with Stepper Motors >

If you’re looking for precise motion with easy setup, then stepper motors should be your first choice when building or upgrading a machine.
What You Need to Know When Selecting a Drive for Your Stepper Motor

What You Need to Know When Selecting a Drive for Your Stepper Motor >

To get the most out of your stepper motor, you need to pair it with the proper drive. There are three critical elements to keep in mind when making your selection: voltage, current and inductance. Each one plays an important part in a motor’s…
What is considered a low voltage motor?

What is Considered a Low Voltage Motor? >

The Low Voltage Directive defines low voltage from 50 – 1000 Vac, or 120 – 1500 Vdc, which is based on the mains voltage used to power the electrical system and ties in with specific IEC regulations on safety and risk of shock and arcing. When low…

Why Does My Stepper Motor Get Hot? >

All electric motors heat up during operation, which is simply a product of passing current through a coil of wire. Electric motors use copper wire to form coils that are part of the electromagnetic circuit required to produce rotation. While copper…